FLORIDA – With the Florida Legislature finally in the swing of things, one proposed bill could have a big impact on households with a tree in their yard, as reported by our sister station WKMG.
RELATED: If your neighbor’s tree falls on your property, who is responsible? The answer may surprise you
The bill (SB 724) — dubbed the “Fallen Tree Act” — was first filed in February by state Sen. Jonathan Martin (R-Ft. Myers).
As the name implies, this piece of legislation is aimed at dealing with fallen trees and shrubbery within the state. Its Legislative purpose reads as follows:
“The Legislature finds that trees and shrubs, and the branches thereof, may cause damage to property when they grow or fall and that such damage is costly to property owners.
The Legislature further finds that Florida’s population growth over the past half-century has largely been located in neighborhoods with residences located on small lots with trees and shrubs that grow precariously close to property lines, with branches or roots encroaching over and under structures on neighboring properties or hanging close enough to cause damage to such properties should such trees or shrubs, or branches thereof, fall...
The Legislature finds that property owners who suffer damage when neighbors’ trees or shrubs fall are responsible for repairing such damage, which can cause their insurance premiums to rise or insurance companies to cancel their policies, and that the property owner whose trees or shrubs create such damage is not liable for the damage, absent a showing of negligence on his or her part.”
Senate Bill 724
Currently, property owners in the state are allowed to take down branches and roots that encroach over their property line from a neighboring plot of land.
However, if a tree or shrub is growing on two separate properties, then both owners would have to agree before the plant can be removed — a situation that can be an issue if a person’s home is at risk of a falling tree.
And that’s where this bill comes in.
Under SB 724, property owners would be liable if a tree or shrub (or any branches on the plant) falls onto a neighbor’s property and causes damage.
“The location where the tree or shrub is or was rooted in the ground determines ownership of such tree or shrub and the branches thereof,” the bill reads.
VIDEO: Massive tree falls on Florida home in trimming accident
Furthermore, the bill would allow a property owner to remove a tree or shrub from his/her property even if the plant is growing on two or more parcels of land. To do so, an owner would simply have to give 30 days’ written notice to the other property owner(s).
The only exception included in the bill is if a property is over 5 acres.
“The purpose of this act is to protect property owners from bearing the burden of responsibility when they suffer damage to their property caused by trees or shrubs located on neighboring property,” the bill continues.
SB 724 was debated earlier this month during a Senate commission meeting, where Sen. Martin compared it to several other rules on the books.
“That would follow all the other court laws that we have — car crashes, dog bites, slip-and-falls, or anything that somebody has control over," he said. “They’re responsible for the upkeep. They’re responsible for the maintenance.”
Martin explained that the bill aims to address issues with smaller lots of land, where residents who don’t take care of their trees could pose a bigger risk to their neighbors.
In response, lobbyist George Feijoo with the Florida Insurance Council posited that the bill could create significant challenges when it comes to insurance and hurricane recovery.
“We’re particularly concerned that the bill will lead to increased litigation, specifically between neighbors, which is not sound public policy to incentivize in our opinion,” he said. “The bill imposes strict liability, even for healthy trees.”
Mark Friedlander of the Florida Insurance Information Institute talked about his concerns with the bill.
“The Florida office of insurance regulation showed that in the fourth quarter of last year, the average rates paid by Florida homeowners decreased by 0.7% now that’s not a big decrease, but the point is, it’s the first decrease we’ve seen in Florida home premiums in a decade,” Friedlander said. “Why did it finally come down? It’s because of less litigation and any legislation that could potentially increase the volume of lawsuits being filed against property insurers could increase rates again. So that’s why we’re concerned that this bill clearly has some red flags with the potential of increasing litigation if the liability falls on the other party for every type of tree damage, regardless of reason why or condition.”
Regardless, the bill was approved by the committee by a unanimous vote. It now faces the hurdle of two more committee meetings before it can be considered by the Senate at large.
If approved and signed into law, the bill will take effect on July 1.